Conspiring To Argue header image 1

Medical Mysteries: God, Aliens, And Acupuncture

October 15th, 2017


This week Ted and JJ discuss first, a man who was miraculously healed after he claims that he saw God in a vision; then woman who was abducted and subsequently healed by grey aliens; and finally, a definitive tearing down of most alternative medicines.

OJ Simpson: Update Update Update

October 6th, 2017


The juice is back, y'all. Join Ted and JJ as explore what OJ Simpson has been up to lately including jail, music videos, and the television show Juiced!

Starchild Skull: Life of Pye

September 25th, 2017


In without a doubt the most rambling episode yet, Ted and JJ discuss the Starchild Skull. Found in Mexico in the 1930s, the Starchild Skull is either definitive proof that alien-human hybrids exist, or more likely the skull of a deformed child. Come for the laughs, stay for the logical inconsistencies on Conspiring to Argue!

OJ Simpson Part 2: You Waited For This?

September 18th, 2017


From the bottom of our collective heart, we apologize for the delay, but here, in all of its glory is the thrilling conclusion to our series on OJ Simpson? Who murdered Nicole Brown and Ron Goldman? You won't find that out on this episode, but stick around and you might find some entertainment anyway!

OJ Simpson Part 1: The Last Hertz Spokesperson

August 27th, 2017


NOTE: Edited due to sound issues. All right you vultures, you asked for it. This week, The Juice is... well we drink the juice. We drink a lot as we dive into part one of our series on Orenthal James Simpson and the murder of Nicole Brown. This week we cover the background; who is OJ Simpson? Why was this case so prolific? What sinister role does Hertz Rent-a-Car play in the case? All of this and not much more on Conspiring to Argue.

Titanic: The Conspiracy Will Go On

August 21st, 2017


*Pennywhistle playing over a dramatic reading of these show notes:

This week Nic and JJ try really hard not to argue about James Cameron's Titanic, and instead argue about whether or not the ship that sank in 1912 actually WAS the Titanic! Join the fun, but watch out for icebergs!

Zombies: Got Brains?

August 13th, 2017


BRAINS... and more this week as Nic and JJ debate whether it's possible for a zombie outbreak to lead to an apocalypse! Plus, Nic loses a bet and drinks vodka!

Cartoon Theories: Toonin’ And Boozin’

August 7th, 2017


This week on Conspiring To Argue, prepare to have the remaining pure memories of your childhood ruined as Nic and JJ discuss seven alternate cartoon theories! As a bonus, the boys propose their own theories as well! Tune in!

Georgia Guidestones: Rumple Vomitze

August 1st, 2017


This week on Conspiring to Argue: tons and tons of granite, the deep South, and possibly the New World Order! Things get rocky this week as Nic and JJ discuss the GEORGIA GUIDESTONES. What do they mean? Who commissioned them? Why are they here? All that and more on Conspiring to Argue.

Amanda Knox: Looking for Amanda Help Me Murder My Roommate

July 23rd, 2017


In 2007, while studying abroad in Italy, Meredith Kercher was brutally murdered. Her roommate, Amanda Knox, and Amanda's boyfriend Rafaela, were initially blamed for the death. Nic and JJ debate whether Amanda actually was guilty, and if she wasn't, who actually committed this heinous slaying. 




Intro Music:

"Pumpkin Juice"
by Eddie Lovecraft
2014 - Licensed under
Creative Commons
Attribution Noncommercial (3.0)

Outro Music:

by AT3000

- Older Posts »